Blog

Do 90% Win Rate Trading Strategies Actually Work?

By Keel Research Team
Updated November 17, 2026

A 90% win rate is easier to get than it sounds, and on its own it says very little about whether a strategy makes money. We sorted every rule test on our backtested strategy pages by win rate. Of 84 tests, none won 90% of its trades, 13 won more than 60%, and 8 of those 13 lost money. The one strategy in our data that won every trade it closed, a DCA bot, lost 19.64% of the account.

Every test here ran on Hyperliquid perpetual futures from 2024-08-15 to 2026-09-29, after trading fees, slippage and funding. The backtested pages were run on 2026-11-17, and this post uses those runs.

How to achieve a 90% win rate in trading, and what it costs

Win rate counts how often a trade closes in profit. It says nothing about how much each win makes or how much each loss costs. Two habits push it up:

  • Take profit early. A small target is hit often, so most trades close as wins.
  • Hold on to losers. A trade that never closes at a loss never counts as a losing trade. A wide stop, or no stop at all, does this.

Both habits raise the win rate and shrink the payoff. A strategy that wins small and loses big can win most of its trades and still lose money. The win rate you need depends on how your average win compares with your average loss, and the win rate calculator works out the break-even point for any risk and reward.

The DCA bot that never closed a losing trade

The DCA bot backtest buys BTC, ETH, SOL, XRP and DOGE when the 14-period RSI on 4h candles is below 40. If the price then falls 3% from its last buy, it buys again, up to 4 more times. It sells when the price is 3% above its average entry. It has no stop loss.

It closed 52 trades and every one of them was a win: a win rate of 100%. Over the same window it lost 19.64% of the account, and its worst drawdown was 49.72%.

The loss sat in the trades it had not closed. A deal only closes at its target, so in a long fall every extra buy fills and the position waits at a loss. At the end of the test the open positions were down by more than all the closed trades had made. Over the whole test, funding on the positions it held cost 8.33% of the account, and trading fees took another 0.59%.

This is a common shape for a very high win rate: many small wins, and the losses kept open until they are too big to ignore.

84 rule tests, sorted by win rate

Each backtested strategy page runs one well-known rule on the 10 most traded Hyperliquid perps, on 4h and 1d candles, long only and long and short. That makes 4 tests for each of 21 rules, 84 tests in all. The chart puts each test's win rate against its total return.

Win rate against total return, rule tests
Win rate against total return, rule testsMade moneyLost moneyDCA bot (5 coins)-100%-50%0%50%100%150%0%20%40%60%80%100%Win rateTotal returnGolden cross, 1d, long only: win rate 5%, total return -17.02%200 EMA, 1d, long only: win rate 10.84%, total return -5.97%200 EMA, 1d, long and short: win rate 12.14%, total return -31.52%200 EMA, 4h, long and short: win rate 13.83%, total return 109.13%200 EMA, 4h, long only: win rate 14.96%, total return 107.13%Golden cross, 1d, long and short: win rate 15%, total return -48.96%Ichimoku Cloud, 1d, long only: win rate 20.28%, total return 94.49%Ichimoku Cloud, 4h, long and short: win rate 21.18%, total return 10.33%Ichimoku Cloud, 4h, long only: win rate 21.31%, total return 39.84%Ichimoku Cloud, 1d, long and short: win rate 23.24%, total return 105.77%EMA crossover, 4h, long and short: win rate 27.84%, total return -0.34%EMA crossover, 4h, long only: win rate 27.97%, total return 42.1%Momentum (trend following), 4h, long only: win rate 28.24%, total return 5.38%EMA crossover, 1d, long and short: win rate 28.3%, total return 54.64%Momentum (trend following), 4h, long and short: win rate 28.78%, total return -45.1%ADX, 4h, long only: win rate 28.92%, total return 45%EMA crossover, 1d, long only: win rate 29.87%, total return 81.07%Golden cross, 4h, long only: win rate 30.37%, total return 82.96%ADX, 1d, long only: win rate 30.95%, total return 68.97%Momentum (trend following), 1d, long only: win rate 31.73%, total return 99.79%ADX, 4h, long and short: win rate 31.83%, total return 14.36%Golden cross, 4h, long and short: win rate 31.88%, total return 62.92%Heikin Ashi, 4h, long only: win rate 32.03%, total return -13.81%MACD, 1d, long and short: win rate 32.15%, total return -22.05%Supertrend, 1d, long only: win rate 32.22%, total return 72.58%Heikin Ashi, 4h, long and short: win rate 32.26%, total return -61.88%Momentum (trend following), 1d, long and short: win rate 32.32%, total return 94.46%MACD, 4h, long only: win rate 32.66%, total return 47.08%Heikin Ashi, 1d, long only: win rate 32.91%, total return 40.6%Supertrend, 1d, long and short: win rate 33.33%, total return 58.14%MACD, 4h, long and short: win rate 33.53%, total return 3.8%MACD, 1d, long only: win rate 33.69%, total return 21.88%Breakout (Donchian / turtle), 1d, long and short: win rate 33.89%, total return 11.45%Heikin Ashi, 1d, long and short: win rate 34.27%, total return -0.57%Fair value gap (FVG), 1d, long only: win rate 34.35%, total return -9.78%Breakout (Donchian / turtle), 4h, long only: win rate 34.49%, total return 67.03%Breakout (Donchian / turtle), 4h, long and short: win rate 35.28%, total return 29.14%Supertrend, 4h, long only: win rate 35.36%, total return 70.65%Keltner Channel, 4h, long and short: win rate 35.62%, total return 25.07%Fair value gap (FVG), 4h, long only: win rate 36.32%, total return -8.13%Supertrend, 4h, long and short: win rate 36.45%, total return 34.16%Keltner Channel, 1d, long and short: win rate 36.55%, total return 50.15%Liquidity sweep, 1d, long only: win rate 36.57%, total return -15.96%Liquidity sweep, 4h, long only: win rate 36.82%, total return -17.92%Break of structure (BOS), 4h, long only: win rate 37.27%, total return 6.28%Break of structure (BOS), 4h, long and short: win rate 37.37%, total return 4.27%ADX, 1d, long and short: win rate 37.66%, total return 81.57%Break of structure (BOS), 1d, long and short: win rate 38.23%, total return -2.5%Parabolic SAR, 1d, long and short: win rate 38.26%, total return 15.48%Keltner Channel, 4h, long only: win rate 38.33%, total return 76.91%Keltner Channel, 1d, long only: win rate 38.82%, total return 72.79%Order blocks, 4h, long only: win rate 38.89%, total return 0.22%Order blocks, 4h, long and short: win rate 38.91%, total return -7.82%Parabolic SAR, 4h, long only: win rate 38.95%, total return 76.72%Parabolic SAR, 4h, long and short: win rate 39.19%, total return 57.66%Parabolic SAR, 1d, long only: win rate 39.74%, total return 52.58%Breakout (Donchian / turtle), 1d, long only: win rate 40.24%, total return 79.92%Liquidity sweep, 1d, long and short: win rate 40.73%, total return -19.87%Fair value gap (FVG), 4h, long and short: win rate 41.25%, total return -21.82%Liquidity sweep, 4h, long and short: win rate 41.63%, total return -38.94%Order blocks, 1d, long only: win rate 42.22%, total return 6.63%Order blocks, 1d, long and short: win rate 42.42%, total return 15.26%Break of structure (BOS), 1d, long only: win rate 44.37%, total return 29.27%Fair value gap (FVG), 1d, long and short: win rate 46.45%, total return 9.82%RSI, 1d, long only: win rate 48.72%, total return -2.45%RSI, 1d, long and short: win rate 52.43%, total return -44.37%VWAP, 1d, long and short: win rate 56.55%, total return -43.52%VWAP, 4h, long only: win rate 57%, total return 3.81%VWAP, 4h, long and short: win rate 57.23%, total return -55.89%VWAP, 1d, long only: win rate 58.18%, total return 6.72%Stochastic, 4h, long only: win rate 59.21%, total return -9.16%Stochastic, 4h, long and short: win rate 60.49%, total return -69.6%Mean reversion, 4h, long only: win rate 61.09%, total return 10.63%Mean reversion, 4h, long and short: win rate 61.46%, total return -54.38%Bollinger Bands, 4h, long only: win rate 62.46%, total return -4.58%Stochastic, 1d, long and short: win rate 63.61%, total return -35.98%Mean reversion, 1d, long and short: win rate 63.64%, total return -47.69%Bollinger Bands, 4h, long and short: win rate 63.88%, total return -63.15%RSI, 4h, long and short: win rate 63.91%, total return -40.77%Bollinger Bands, 1d, long and short: win rate 65.06%, total return -51.45%Stochastic, 1d, long only: win rate 66.67%, total return 22.42%Mean reversion, 1d, long only: win rate 67.37%, total return 19.2%RSI, 4h, long only: win rate 67.46%, total return 23.65%Bollinger Bands, 1d, long only: win rate 69.23%, total return 15.47%DCA bot, 4h, long only: win rate 100%, total return -19.64%
Each dot is one rule run on the top 10 Hyperliquid perps at one timeframe and direction, 2024-08-15 to 2026-09-29, after fees, slippage and funding. Win rate is the share of round trips closed at a profit.

Three things stand out.

No rule test came close to 90%. The highest win rate was 69.23%.

High win rates lost money more often than not. 13 tests won more than 60% of their trades, and 8 of them lost money. Their median return was a loss of 35.98%. All 13 came from 4 rules that buy dips and short rallies: Bollinger Bands, RSI, stochastic and mean reversion. Most of their trades close at a small profit, and the few that keep going the wrong way are the big losses. The clearest case is Bollinger Bands on 1d candles, long and short: it won 65.06% of 279 trades and lost 51.45%.

Low win rates often made the most. 56 tests won less than 40% of their trades, and 40 of those made money, with a median return of 31.65%. The 200 EMA rule on 4h candles, long and short, won 13.83% of 1,499 trades and returned 109.13%. Trend rules like this one take many small losses and make their money on a few long moves.

RuleTimeframeDirectionWin rateReturnTradesMax drawdown
Bollinger Bands1dLong only69.23%+15.47%130−30.73%
RSI4hLong only67.46%+23.65%335−26.33%
Mean reversion1dLong only67.37%+19.20%95−30.39%
Stochastic1dLong only66.67%+22.42%198−37.32%
Bollinger Bands1dLong and short65.06%−51.45%279−54.82%
RSI4hLong and short63.91%−40.77%691−43.85%
Bollinger Bands4hLong and short63.88%−63.15%1,704−65.77%
Mean reversion1dLong and short63.64%−47.69%208−52.74%
Stochastic1dLong and short63.61%−35.98%369−48.81%
Bollinger Bands4hLong only62.46%−4.58%851−25.79%
Mean reversion4hLong and short61.46%−54.38%1,262−57.76%
Mean reversion4hLong only61.09%+10.63%623−22.70%
Stochastic4hLong and short60.49%−69.60%2,244−72.72%
Every rule test with a win rate above 60%, highest first.
RuleTimeframeDirectionWin rateReturnTradesMax drawdown
200 EMA4hLong and short13.83%+109.13%1,499−37.45%
200 EMA4hLong only14.96%+107.13%752−39.20%
Ichimoku Cloud1dLong and short23.24%+105.77%350−44.84%
Momentum (trend following)1dLong only31.73%+99.79%385−41.19%
Ichimoku Cloud1dLong only20.28%+94.49%153−33.25%
The 5 rule tests with a win rate below 40% that returned the most.

Single coins tell the same story

Each backtested page also runs its rule on every coin alone. We counted the single-coin tests with at least 30 trades, 295 of them. 43 won more than 60% of their trades, and 41 of those 43 lost money.

A low win rate is no promise either. Of the 194 single-coin tests that won less than 40% of their trades, 65 made money. Win rate just doesn't sort winners from losers.

Where a high win rate did pay

Our study of 30 crypto bot strategies shows the other side. There, 9 strategies won more than 60% of their trades, and none of them lost money. The Regime-Gated Crypto Index won 80.47% of its trades and returned 196.85%. The best return in the study, 408.84%, came from the MACD crossover strategy, which won 60.2%.

Win rate against total return, the 30-strategy study
Win rate against total return, the 30-strategy studyMade moneyLost money-100%0%100%200%300%400%500%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%Win rateTotal returnMean Reversion Strategy on Hyperliquid: win rate 34.4%, total return 4.45%Channel Breakout Strategy on Hyperliquid: win rate 34.95%, total return 126.99%Long HYPE / Short Alts Index (Market-Neutral): win rate 35.37%, total return 123.65%MA Crossover (Golden Cross) Strategy: win rate 36.96%, total return 130.85%Bollinger Bands: win rate 37.92%, total return -2.32%Pairs Trading: win rate 39.95%, total return 3.93%RSI Trend Pullback: win rate 41.03%, total return 19.38%VWAP Reversion: win rate 41.36%, total return -85.99%Grid: win rate 44.51%, total return 2.28%Mean Reversion Regime: win rate 44.65%, total return -18.19%TTM Squeeze: win rate 45.02%, total return -17.23%Funding Carry (Cross-Sectional, Hyperliquid): win rate 48.21%, total return 49.19%Momentum + Funding Strategy on Hyperliquid: win rate 48.9%, total return 124.23%Momentum Strategy on Hyperliquid: win rate 49.03%, total return 151.04%Delta Neutral: win rate 49.14%, total return -28.58%Short Squeeze: win rate 51.84%, total return -21.43%Multi-Indicator Confluence (Crypto): win rate 55.05%, total return 262.11%Stochastic Oversold-Reversal (Crypto): win rate 55.41%, total return 128.19%Rebalancing Index: win rate 55.74%, total return -4.82%Ichimoku Cloud Strategy (Crypto Perps): win rate 58.64%, total return 115.44%Supertrend + Bollinger Combo (Crypto Perps): win rate 58.97%, total return 385.07%MACD Crossover Strategy (Crypto): win rate 60.2%, total return 408.84%Vol Targeting: win rate 63.53%, total return 85.56%ADX Trend-Strength Strategy (Crypto): win rate 63.62%, total return 81.64%RSI Oversold-Recovery Strategy (Crypto): win rate 65.62%, total return 33.66%Supertrend Strategy (Crypto Perps): win rate 67.22%, total return 105.03%AI Trading Bot Strategy (Trend Wrapper): win rate 70.56%, total return 213.38%Supertrend Crypto B: win rate 73.81%, total return 30.69%Regime Rotation (BTC Trend Switch): win rate 78.16%, total return 102.36%Regime-Gated Crypto Index (Risk-Managed, Top-15): win rate 80.47%, total return 196.85%
Each dot is one strategy from the bot study, same window and costs. Here every order that shrinks a position counts as a trade, so trimming a winner counts as a win.

Two things set this set apart from the rule tests:

  • It is not a random sample. 7 of those 9 strategies are in our strategy library, where we publish strategies that held up in testing. They come with their own sizing and exits, not a bare textbook rule.
  • The study counts trades differently. Every order that makes a position smaller counts as a trade, so trimming a winning position back to its target size counts as a win. Strategies that rebalance often, like the index ones, collect many of those.

Low win rates did well here too: of the 6 strategies that won less than 40% of their trades, 5 made money.

StrategyWin rateReturnProfit factorTrades
Regime-Gated Crypto Index (Risk-Managed, Top-15)80.47%+196.85%2.30394
Regime Rotation (BTC Trend Switch)78.16%+102.36%3.0091
Supertrend Crypto B73.81%+30.69%1.44379
AI Trading Bot Strategy (Trend Wrapper)70.56%+213.38%1.501,141
Supertrend Strategy (Crypto Perps)67.22%+105.03%1.42679
RSI Oversold-Recovery Strategy (Crypto)65.62%+33.66%8.7332
ADX Trend-Strength Strategy (Crypto)63.62%+81.64%1.211,403
Vol Targeting63.53%+85.56%2.55339
MACD Crossover Strategy (Crypto)60.20%+408.84%1.352,746
Every strategy in the study with a win rate above 60%. Profit factor is gross profit divided by gross loss.

Win rate vs risk reward: what to check instead

A high win rate trading strategy can work, as long as its average loss stays small next to its average win. The habits that raise a win rate tend to make the losses bigger, so check these before you trust one:

  • Profit factor: gross profit divided by gross loss. Above one means the wins outweigh the losses. The profit factor calculator works it out from your own trade list.
  • Return after costs: fees, slippage and, on perps, funding. The DCA bot paid more in funding than it paid in fees.
  • Worst drawdown: the biggest drop from a peak. A strategy that wins 100% of its closed trades can still fall 49.72%, as the DCA bot did. The max drawdown calculator shows what a given drop takes to recover.
  • Open trades: a strategy with no stop can hold its losses in positions it hasn't closed. Look at the equity curve, not only the closed trades.
  • Trade count: a win rate from a handful of trades says little, which is why we only counted single-coin tests with at least 30 trades.

So, does a trading strategy with a 90% win rate work? In our tests the only one that got there did it by never closing a losing trade, and it lost money. Judge a strategy by what it makes after costs and how far it falls on the way, and treat the win rate as a detail.

How we tested

  • Data: Hyperliquid perpetual futures from 2024-08-15 to 2026-09-29.
  • Costs: 4.5 basis points of trading fee and 4.5 of slippage on every trade, plus Hyperliquid's hourly funding on every open position.
  • Rule tests: the 21 rules on our backtested pages, each on the 10 most traded Hyperliquid perps, on 4h and 1d candles, long only and long and short. Each coin trades its own signal with a tenth of the account.
  • Win rate: on the backtested pages, the share of round trips (opening a position to closing it) that closed at a profit. In the bot study, every order that makes a position smaller counts as a trade.
  • No new runs: every number here comes from the published pages, as run on 2026-11-17. Those pages are re-run when our backtest engine changes, so a page you open later can show different numbers from this post.

A backtest is evidence about one window, not a promise. Every strategy here can lose money, and none of this is investment advice.

Test your own strategy

Keel runs the backtests behind these pages. Describe a strategy in plain words, from the Keel app or an assistant such as Claude or ChatGPT, and Keel backtests it on Hyperliquid data with fees, slippage and funding. You see the win rate next to the return, the drawdown and every trade, and you can paper trade it on live prices before any money is at risk.

See more than the win rate

Backtest your strategy on Hyperliquid data with fees, slippage and funding, and read its win rate next to its return and worst drawdown.

Backtest a strategy free